Kitchen Cabinet Refacing vs. Replacement: Pros and Cons of Each Option

kitchen cabinet refacing vs replacement

It’s time for your kitchen to get an upgrade — but should you choose to reface or replace your cabinets? The option you pick will play a big part in the trajectory of your remodel. Each choice comes with its own considerations based on cost, time, and more. Let’s delve into the pros and cons of kitchen cabinet refacing and replacement to help you make an informed decision.

Cabinet Refacing Pros:


Refacing cabinets is generally more budget-friendly than a full replacement. It allows you to achieve a fresh, updated look without the hefty price tag of new cabinetry.


Cabinet refacing is also a quicker process compared to a complete replacement. Because the installation involves applying a new veneer or finish to the existing cabinet frames — rather than swapping out the whole thing — it can significantly reduce the time your kitchen is out of commission.

Environmentally Friendly

You’ll minimize waste and contribute to sustainability if you opt to keep your existing cabinets. It’s always a plus when you can reduce the environmental impact associated with a remodeling project.

Keep Your Current Layout

If you’re satisfied with the arrangement and functionality of your current cabinets, refacing is quick and cost effective with the added bonus of preserving the structure of your current kitchen.

Cabinet Refacing Cons:

Limited Options

While refacing can refresh the look of your cabinets, it may not provide the same level of transformation as a complete replacement. If you’re looking for a drastic change or need to address structural issues, replacement might be the way to go. Refacing also limits your choices in terms of materials and styles. You’re working with the existing framework, which can restrict the range of finishes, door styles, and hardware you can select.

Not Suitable for All Cabinets

Cabinets in poor structural condition or those with water damage may not be ideal candidates for refacing. In such cases, replacement might be the more practical solution.

Cabinet Replacement Pros:

Wider Material and Style Choices

If you’re starting from scratch, you’ll have the flexibility to switch up materials, styles, and finishes. Cabinet replacement provides a complete overhaul of your kitchen’s aesthetic. This option is perfect if you want a brand-new look, increased storage space, or a more customized design.

Address Structural Issues

If your existing cabinets are showing signs of wear, damage, or are poorly configured, replacement allows you to address these structural concerns. This is particularly important for long-term durability and functionality. New cabinets will be well-constructed and built to last.

Cabinet Replacement Cons

Higher Cost

The most significant drawback of cabinet replacement is the price tag. Because it involves more new material and more involved installation, it can be much more expensive

Extended Downtime

Unlike refacing, replacing cabinets involves a more extended period of downtime for your kitchen. The removal and installation process can disrupt your daily routine for a long time.

Environmental Impact

Choosing cabinet replacement contributes to a higher environmental impact due to the production and disposal of the old cabinets. While some materials can be recycled, the overall process is less environmentally friendly than refacing.

Consult the Experts

If you’re ready to remodel your kitchen, Modern Touch Contracting is ready to bring your vision to life. With extensive experience in both remodeling and refacing cabinets, we can help you determine which option is best for you. Schedule your consultation today.